finally some proper validation

src/ytdl_sub/config/overrides.py

@@ -67,10 +67,11 @@ class Overrides(DictFormatterValidator, Scriptable):
         )
         return ScriptUtils.add_sanitized_variables(initial_variables)
 
-    def initialize_script(self, unresolved_variables: Dict[str, str]) -> None:
+    def initialize_script(self, unresolved_variables: Dict[str, str]) -> "Overrides":
         self.script.add(self.initial_variables(unresolved_variables=unresolved_variables))
         self.unresolvable.update(set(unresolved_variables.keys()))
         self.update_script()
+        return self
 
     @property
     def subscription_name(self) -> str:

src/ytdl_sub/config/plugin.py

@@ -1,5 +1,6 @@
 from abc import ABC
 from abc import abstractmethod
+from enum import Enum
 from typing import Dict
 from typing import Generic
 from typing import List
@@ -20,6 +21,8 @@ class PluginPriority:
     Defines priority for plugins, 0 is highest priority
     """
 
+    MODIFY_ENTRY_SPLIT = 9
+
     # If modify_entry priority is >= to this value, run after split
     MODIFY_ENTRY_AFTER_SPLIT = 10
 
@@ -144,6 +147,8 @@ class SplitPlugin(Plugin[TOptionsValidator], Generic[TOptionsValidator], ABC):
     Plugin that splits entries into zero or more entries
     """
 
+    priority = PluginPriority(modify_entry_metadata=PluginPriority.MODIFY_ENTRY_SPLIT)
+
     @abstractmethod
     def split(self, entry: Entry) -> List[Tuple[Entry, FileMetadata]]:
         """

src/ytdl_sub/config/preset.py

@@ -18,6 +18,7 @@ from ytdl_sub.config.plugin import Plugin
 from ytdl_sub.config.plugin_mapping import PluginMapping
 from ytdl_sub.config.preset_options import OptionsValidator
 from ytdl_sub.config.preset_options import OutputOptions
+from ytdl_sub.config.preset_options import PluginOperation
 from ytdl_sub.config.preset_options import TOptionsValidator
 from ytdl_sub.config.preset_options import YTDLOptions
 from ytdl_sub.downloaders.url.validators import MultiUrlValidator
@@ -26,13 +27,11 @@ from ytdl_sub.entries.script.variable_scripts import VARIABLE_SCRIPTS
 from ytdl_sub.prebuilt_presets import PREBUILT_PRESET_NAMES
 from ytdl_sub.prebuilt_presets import PUBLISHED_PRESET_NAMES
 from ytdl_sub.script.script import Script
-from ytdl_sub.script.script import ScriptBuilder
 from ytdl_sub.script.utils.exceptions import VariableDoesNotExist
 from ytdl_sub.utils.exceptions import StringFormattingVariableNotFoundException
 from ytdl_sub.utils.exceptions import ValidationException
 from ytdl_sub.utils.logger import Logger
 from ytdl_sub.utils.script import ScriptUtils
-from ytdl_sub.utils.scriptable import Scriptable
 from ytdl_sub.utils.yaml import dump_yaml
 from ytdl_sub.validators.strict_dict_validator import StrictDictValidator
 from ytdl_sub.validators.string_formatter_validators import DictFormatterValidator
@@ -168,35 +167,19 @@ class Preset(_PresetShell):
         return list(VARIABLE_SCRIPTS.keys())
 
     @property
-    def _added_variables(self) -> Dict[str, str]:
+    def _added_variables(self) -> Set[str]:
-        added_variables: Dict[str, str] = {
+        added_variables: Set[str] = set()
-            var_name: "dummy_string"
+        options: List[OptionsValidator] = self.plugins.plugin_options
-            for var_name in self.downloader_options.added_source_variables()
+        options.append(self.downloader_options)
-        }
+
+        for plugin_options in options:
+            for plugin_added_variables in plugin_options.added_source_variables(
+                unresolved_variables=set()
+            ).values():
+                added_variables |= set(plugin_added_variables)
 
-        for plugin_options in self.plugins.plugin_options:
-            for source_var in plugin_options.added_source_variables():
-                added_variables[source_var] = "dummy_string"
         return added_variables
 
-    @functools.cached_property
-    def _script_builder(self) -> ScriptBuilder:
-        # Set the formatter variables to be the overrides
-        script = ScriptBuilder(
-            self.overrides.initial_variables(unresolved_variables=self._added_variables)
-        )
-        script.add_resolved(ScriptUtils.add_dummy_variables(self._source_variables))
-        return script
-
-    @functools.cached_property
-    def _script(self) -> Script:
-        """
-        Contains actualized script which should hold all Override variables
-        """
-        return self._script_builder.add_resolved(
-            ScriptUtils.add_dummy_variables(self._added_variables)
-        ).partial_build()
-
     def __validate_and_get_plugins(self) -> PresetPlugins:
         preset_plugins = PresetPlugins()
 
@@ -211,21 +194,43 @@ class Preset(_PresetShell):
 
         return preset_plugins
 
-    def __validate_added_variables(self):
+    def _validate_added_variables(self) -> Script:
-        script_builder = copy.deepcopy(self._script_builder)
+        """
-        self.downloader_options.validate_with_variables(script=script_builder.partial_build())
+        Validate variables resolve as plugins are executed, and return
-        script_builder.add_resolved(
+        a mock script which contains actualized added variables from the plugins
-            ScriptUtils.add_dummy_variables(self.downloader_options.added_source_variables())
+        """
+        script = copy.deepcopy(self.overrides.script).add(
+            ScriptUtils.add_dummy_variables(self._source_variables)
         )
+        unresolved_variables = copy.deepcopy(self._added_variables)
+
+        added_variables: Set[str] = self.downloader_options.added_source_variables(
+            unresolved_variables
+        ).get(PluginOperation.DOWNLOADER, set())
+        script.add(ScriptUtils.add_dummy_variables(added_variables))
+        unresolved_variables -= added_variables
+
+        for _, plugin_options in sorted(
+            self.plugins.zipped(), key=lambda pl: pl[0].priority.modify_entry_metadata
+        ):
+            added_variables = plugin_options.added_source_variables(
+                unresolved_variables=unresolved_variables
+            ).get(PluginOperation.MODIFY_ENTRY_METADATA, set())
+            script.add(ScriptUtils.add_dummy_variables(added_variables))
+            unresolved_variables -= added_variables
 
         for _, plugin_options in sorted(
             self.plugins.zipped(), key=lambda pl: pl[0].priority.modify_entry
         ):
-            # Validate current plugin using source + added plugin variables
+            added_variables = plugin_options.added_source_variables(
-            plugin_options.validate_with_variables(script=script_builder.partial_build())
+                unresolved_variables=unresolved_variables
-            script_builder.add_resolved(
+            ).get(PluginOperation.MODIFY_ENTRY, set())
-                ScriptUtils.add_dummy_variables(self.downloader_options.added_source_variables())
+            script.add(ScriptUtils.add_dummy_variables(added_variables))
-            )
+            unresolved_variables -= added_variables
+
+        assert not unresolved_variables
+        _ = script.resolve(update=True)
+        return script
 
     @functools.cache
     def _get_unresolvable_variables(
@@ -233,7 +238,7 @@ class Preset(_PresetShell):
         formatter_validator: Union[StringFormatterValidator, OverridesStringFormatterValidator],
     ) -> Optional[Set[str]]:
         unresolvable = (
-            set([VARIABLES.entry_metadata.variable_name] + list(self._added_variables.keys()))
+            self._added_variables.union([VARIABLES.entry_metadata.variable_name])
             if isinstance(formatter_validator, OverridesStringFormatterValidator)
             else None
         )
@@ -241,10 +246,11 @@ class Preset(_PresetShell):
 
     def __validate_override_string_formatter_validator(
         self,
+        mock_script: Script,
         formatter_validator: Union[StringFormatterValidator, OverridesStringFormatterValidator],
     ) -> None:
         try:
-            self._script.resolve_once(
+            mock_script.resolve_once(
                 {"tmp_var": formatter_validator.format_string},
                 unresolvable=self._get_unresolvable_variables(formatter_validator),
             )
@@ -253,6 +259,7 @@ class Preset(_PresetShell):
 
     def __recursive_preset_validate(
         self,
+        mock_script: Script,
         validator: Optional[Validator] = None,
     ) -> None:
         """
@@ -267,16 +274,20 @@ class Preset(_PresetShell):
             # Usage of protected variables in other validators is fine. The reason to keep
             # them protected is for readability when using them in subscriptions.
             for validator_value in validator._validator_dict.values():
-                self.__recursive_preset_validate(validator_value)
+                self.__recursive_preset_validate(mock_script=mock_script, validator=validator_value)
             # pylint: enable=protected-access
         elif isinstance(validator, ListValidator):
             for list_value in validator.list:
-                self.__recursive_preset_validate(list_value)
+                self.__recursive_preset_validate(mock_script=mock_script, validator=list_value)
         elif isinstance(validator, (StringFormatterValidator, OverridesStringFormatterValidator)):
-            self.__validate_override_string_formatter_validator(validator)
+            self.__validate_override_string_formatter_validator(
+                mock_script=mock_script, formatter_validator=validator
+            )
         elif isinstance(validator, (DictFormatterValidator, OverridesDictFormatterValidator)):
             for validator_value in validator.dict.values():
-                self.__validate_override_string_formatter_validator(validator_value)
+                self.__validate_override_string_formatter_validator(
+                    mock_script=mock_script, formatter_validator=validator_value
+                )
 
     def _get_presets_to_merge(
         self, parent_presets: str | List[str], seen_presets: List[str], config: ConfigValidator
@@ -353,21 +364,22 @@ class Preset(_PresetShell):
             key="ytdl_options", validator=YTDLOptions, default={}
         )
 
-        self.overrides = self._validate_key(key="overrides", validator=Overrides, default={})
         self.plugins: PresetPlugins = self.__validate_and_get_plugins()
-        self.__validate_added_variables()
+        self.overrides = self._validate_key(
-
+            key="overrides", validator=Overrides, default={}
-        # After all options are initialized, perform a recursive post-validate that requires
+        ).initialize_script(
-        # values from multiple validators
-        self.__recursive_preset_validate()
-
-        self.overrides.initialize_script(
             unresolved_variables={
                 var_name: f"{{%throw('Plugin variable {var_name} has not been created yet')}}"
                 for var_name in self._added_variables
             }
         )
 
+        mock_script = self._validate_added_variables()
+
+        # After all options are initialized, perform a recursive post-validate that requires
+        # values from multiple validators
+        self.__recursive_preset_validate(mock_script=mock_script)
+
     @property
     def name(self) -> str:
         """

src/ytdl_sub/config/preset_options.py

@@ -1,12 +1,13 @@
 from abc import ABC
+from enum import Enum
 from typing import Any
+from typing import Dict
 from typing import List
 from typing import Optional
+from typing import Set
 from typing import TypeVar
 
 from ytdl_sub.config.defaults import DEFAULT_DOWNLOAD_ARCHIVE_NAME
-from ytdl_sub.script.script import Script
-from ytdl_sub.script.script import ScriptBuilder
 from ytdl_sub.utils.exceptions import ValidationException
 from ytdl_sub.validators.file_path_validators import OverridesStringFormatterFilePathValidator
 from ytdl_sub.validators.file_path_validators import StringFormatterFileNameValidator
@@ -20,6 +21,12 @@ from ytdl_sub.validators.validators import LiteralDictValidator
 from ytdl_sub.validators.validators import Validator
 
 
+class PluginOperation(Enum):
+    DOWNLOADER = -1
+    MODIFY_ENTRY_METADATA = 0
+    MODIFY_ENTRY = 1
+
+
 # pylint: disable=no-self-use
 # pylint: disable=unused-argument
 class OptionsValidator(Validator, ABC):
@@ -44,7 +51,9 @@ class OptionsValidator(Validator, ABC):
         """
         return self._validation_exception(error_message=error_message)
 
-    def added_source_variables(self) -> List[str]:
+    def added_source_variables(
+        self, unresolved_variables: Set[str]
+    ) -> Dict[PluginOperation, Set[str]]:
         """
         If the plugin adds source variables, list them here.
 
@@ -52,18 +61,7 @@ class OptionsValidator(Validator, ABC):
         -------
         List of added source variables this plugin creates
         """
-        return []
+        return {}
-
-    def validate_with_variables(self, script: Script) -> None:
-        """
-        Optional validation after init with the session's source and override variables.
-
-        Parameters
-        ----------
-        script
-            Script containing all current variables
-        """
-        return None
 
 
 TOptionsValidator = TypeVar("TOptionsValidator", bound=OptionsValidator)

src/ytdl_sub/downloaders/url/validators.py

@@ -3,8 +3,10 @@ from typing import Any
 from typing import Dict
 from typing import List
 from typing import Optional
+from typing import Set
 
 from ytdl_sub.config.preset_options import OptionsValidator
+from ytdl_sub.config.preset_options import PluginOperation
 from ytdl_sub.script.script import Script
 from ytdl_sub.script.script import ScriptBuilder
 from ytdl_sub.validators.strict_dict_validator import StrictDictValidator
@@ -245,31 +247,12 @@ class MultiUrlValidator(OptionsValidator):
         # keep for readthedocs documentation
         return self._urls.list[0].variables
 
-    def added_source_variables(self) -> List[str]:
+    def added_source_variables(
+        self, unresolved_variables: Set[str]
+    ) -> Dict[PluginOperation, Set[str]]:
         """
         Returns
         -------
         List of variables added. The first collection url always contains all the variables.
         """
-        return list(self._urls.list[0].variables.keys)
+        return {PluginOperation.DOWNLOADER: set(self._urls.list[0].variables.keys)}
-
-    def validate_with_variables(self, script: Script) -> None:
-        """
-        Ensures new variables added are not existing variables
-        """
-        # Apply formatting to each new source variable, ensure it resolves
-        for collection_url in self.urls.list:
-            script.resolve_once(collection_url.variables.dict_with_format_strings)
-
-        # Ensure at least URL is non-empty
-        has_non_empty_url = False
-        url_variables = {
-            f"tmp_var_url_{idx}": url_validator.url.format_string
-            for idx, url_validator in enumerate(self.urls.list)
-        }
-        output = script.resolve_once(url_variables)
-        for out in output.values():
-            has_non_empty_url |= bool(str(out))
-
-        if not output or not has_non_empty_url:
-            raise self._validation_exception("Must contain at least one url that is non-empty")

src/ytdl_sub/plugins/regex.py

@@ -2,15 +2,18 @@ from typing import Any
 from typing import Dict
 from typing import List
 from typing import Optional
+from typing import Set
 
 from yt_dlp.utils import sanitize_filename
 
 from ytdl_sub.config.plugin import Plugin
 from ytdl_sub.config.plugin import PluginPriority
 from ytdl_sub.config.preset_options import OptionsDictValidator
+from ytdl_sub.config.preset_options import PluginOperation
 from ytdl_sub.entries.entry import Entry
 from ytdl_sub.entries.script.variable_scripts import VARIABLE_SCRIPTS
 from ytdl_sub.entries.variables.kwargs import YTDL_SUB_REGEX_SOURCE_VARS
+from ytdl_sub.script.parser import parse
 from ytdl_sub.script.script import Script
 from ytdl_sub.utils.exceptions import RegexNoMatchException
 from ytdl_sub.utils.exceptions import StringFormattingVariableNotFoundException
@@ -211,27 +214,6 @@ class RegexOptions(OptionsDictValidator):
         """
         return self._skip_if_match_fails
 
-    def validate_with_variables(self, script: Script) -> None:
-        for key, regex_options in self.source_variable_capture_dict.items():
-            # Ensure each variable getting captured is a source variable
-            if key not in script._variables:
-                raise self._validation_exception(
-                    f"cannot regex capture '{key}' because it is not a source or override variable"
-                )
-
-            # Ensure the capture group names are not existing source/override variables
-            for capture_group_name in regex_options.capture_group_names:
-                if capture_group_name in VARIABLE_SCRIPTS:
-                    raise self._validation_exception(
-                        f"'{capture_group_name}' cannot be used as a capture group name because it "
-                        f"is a source variable"
-                    )
-                if capture_group_name in script._variables:
-                    raise self._validation_exception(
-                        f"'{capture_group_name}' cannot be used as a capture group name because it "
-                        f"is an override variable"
-                    )
-
     @property
     def source_variable_capture_dict(self) -> Dict[str, VariableRegex]:
         """
@@ -241,19 +223,39 @@ class RegexOptions(OptionsDictValidator):
         """
         return self._from.variable_capture_dict
 
-    def added_source_variables(self) -> List[str]:
+    def _is_evaluatable_at_metadata_time(
+        self, unresolved_variables: Set[str], input_variable_name: str, regex_options: VariableRegex
+    ) -> bool:
+        if input_variable_name in unresolved_variables:
+            return False
+        for capture_group_default in regex_options.capture_group_defaults:
+            parsed_default = parse(capture_group_default.format_string)
+            if parsed_default.variables.issubset(unresolved_variables):
+                return False
+        return True
+
+    def added_source_variables(
+        self, unresolved_variables: Set[str]
+    ) -> Dict[PluginOperation, Set[str]]:
         """
         Returns
         -------
         List of new source variables created via regex capture
         """
-        added_source_vars: List[str] = []
+        added_source_vars: Dict[PluginOperation, Set[str]] = {
-        for regex_options in self.source_variable_capture_dict.values():
+            PluginOperation.MODIFY_ENTRY_METADATA: set(),
-            added_source_vars.extend(regex_options.capture_group_names)
+            PluginOperation.MODIFY_ENTRY: set(),
-            added_source_vars.extend(
+        }
-                f"{capture_group_name}_sanitized"
+        for input_variable_name, regex_options in self.source_variable_capture_dict.items():
-                for capture_group_name in regex_options.capture_group_names
+            key = PluginOperation.MODIFY_ENTRY
-            )
+            if self._is_evaluatable_at_metadata_time(
+                unresolved_variables=unresolved_variables,
+                input_variable_name=input_variable_name,
+                regex_options=regex_options,
+            ):
+                key = PluginOperation.MODIFY_ENTRY_METADATA
+
+            added_source_vars[key] |= set(regex_options.capture_group_names)
 
         return added_source_vars
 

src/ytdl_sub/plugins/split_by_chapters.py

@@ -1,14 +1,17 @@
 import copy
 from pathlib import Path
 from typing import Any
+from typing import Dict
 from typing import List
 from typing import Optional
+from typing import Set
 from typing import Tuple
 
 from yt_dlp.utils import sanitize_filename
 
 from ytdl_sub.config.plugin import SplitPlugin
 from ytdl_sub.config.preset_options import OptionsDictValidator
+from ytdl_sub.config.preset_options import PluginOperation
 from ytdl_sub.entries.entry import Entry
 from ytdl_sub.entries.variables.kwargs import CHAPTERS
 from ytdl_sub.entries.variables.kwargs import SPLIT_BY_CHAPTERS_PARENT_ENTRY
@@ -81,14 +84,18 @@ class SplitByChaptersOptions(OptionsDictValidator):
             key="when_no_chapters", validator=WhenNoChaptersValidator
         ).value
 
-    def added_source_variables(self) -> List[str]:
+    def added_source_variables(
-        return [
+        self, unresolved_variables: Set[str]
+    ) -> Dict[PluginOperation, Set[str]]:
+        return {
+            PluginOperation.MODIFY_ENTRY: {
                 "chapter_title",
                 "chapter_title_sanitized",
                 "chapter_index",
                 "chapter_index_padded",
                 "chapter_count",
-        ]
+            }
+        }
 
     @property
     def when_no_chapters(self) -> str:

src/ytdl_sub/plugins/subtitles.py

@@ -2,9 +2,11 @@ from pathlib import Path
 from typing import Dict
 from typing import List
 from typing import Optional
+from typing import Set
 
 from ytdl_sub.config.plugin import Plugin
 from ytdl_sub.config.preset_options import OptionsDictValidator
+from ytdl_sub.config.preset_options import PluginOperation
 from ytdl_sub.downloaders.ytdl_options_builder import YTDLOptionsBuilder
 from ytdl_sub.entries.entry import Entry
 from ytdl_sub.utils.file_handler import FileHandler
@@ -113,13 +115,15 @@ class SubtitleOptions(OptionsDictValidator):
         """
         return self._allow_auto_generated_subtitles
 
-    def added_source_variables(self) -> List[str]:
+    def added_source_variables(
+        self, unresolved_variables: Set[str]
+    ) -> Dict[PluginOperation, Set[str]]:
         """
         Returns
         -------
         List of new source variables created by using the subtitles plugin
         """
-        return ["lang", "subtitles_ext"]
+        return {PluginOperation.MODIFY_ENTRY: {"lang", "subtitles_ext"}}
 
 
 class SubtitlesPlugin(Plugin[SubtitleOptions]):

src/ytdl_sub/utils/script.py

@@ -9,11 +9,11 @@ from ytdl_sub.script.types.resolvable import String
 
 class ScriptUtils:
     @classmethod
-    def add_dummy_variables(cls, variables: Iterable[str]) -> Dict[str, Resolvable]:
+    def add_dummy_variables(cls, variables: Iterable[str]) -> Dict[str, str]:
-        dummy_variables: Dict[str, Resolvable] = {}
+        dummy_variables: Dict[str, str] = {}
         for var in variables:
-            dummy_variables[var] = String("dummy_string")
+            dummy_variables[var] = ""
-            dummy_variables[f"{var}_sanitized"] = String("dummy_string")
+            dummy_variables[f"{var}_sanitized"] = ""
 
         return dummy_variables