The library quality scanner judged quality by FILE EXTENSION only
(get_quality_tier_from_extension) and read the legacy v2 `qualities` dict —
so every FLAC was "lossless tier 1" regardless of bit depth / sample rate. It
could never flag a 16-bit FLAC as upgradeable under a 24-bit profile, and it
ignored the v3 ranked_targets entirely. Completely inconsistent with the
download guard.
Now both share one core:
- selection.targets_from_profile(profile) — single profile→targets conversion
(v2→v3 migration), reused by load_profile_targets.
- selection.quality_meets_profile(aq, targets) — strict: meets iff the real
measured quality satisfies a ranked target (fallback ignored — it's a
download concession, not a definition of "good enough").
- guards.check_quality_target refactored to use both.
- quality_scanner probes real quality (probe_audio_quality) and checks against
the v3 targets via quality_meets_profile. Extension tier kept only as a
fallback label when a file can't be probed.
Result: the scan flags exactly what the download gate would reject — 16-bit
when you want 24-bit, wrong sample rate, MP3 when you want FLAC.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
d2abec4a92