Real-world regression triggered by the album-bundle work earlier in
2.6.3. Tracks with full Spotify metadata were importing as
``01 - <title>`` under ``Artist - Album/`` (no year), even when the
source filename carried the correct track number and Spotify's
release_date was available.
Investigation via DB inspection of stored wishlist rows:
```
"Never Gonna Give You Up" → track_number=None, release_date=""
"idfc" → track_number=1, release_date=""
"No Sleep Till Brooklyn" → track_number=1, release_date=""
```
Source-of-truth Spotify metadata had release_date AND real track
positions, but the wishlist row was poisoned. Three regressions
compounded the loss:
**Fix A — ``track_object_to_dict`` (``core/wishlist/payloads.py:295``)
preserved only album.name during Track→dict conversion.**
Pre-fix:
```python
album_name = "Unknown Album"
if hasattr(track_object, "album") and track_object.album:
if hasattr(track_object.album, "name"):
album_name = track_object.album.name
else:
album_name = str(track_object.album)
result = {
...
"album": {"name": album_name}, # ← release_date / images / etc. all dropped
...
}
```
When a wishlist payload arrived as a Track dataclass instead of a
raw spotify_data dict, the Track→dict conversion stripped
release_date, images, album_type, total_tracks, id, and album-level
artists. Every wishlist row added through this path landed in the
DB with ``album={'name': X}`` only.
Post-fix: three branches handle the three album shapes
- ``album_attr`` is a dict → ``dict(album_attr)`` preserves every key
- ``album_attr`` is a sub-object → pull all common Album-dataclass
attrs (id, release_date, album_type, total_tracks, images, ...)
- ``album_attr`` is a bare string → build a dict from the track
object's adjacent attrs (release_date, album_id, album_type, ...)
and surface ``image_url`` as ``album.images``
**Fix B — ``core/discovery/playlist.py:309`` only added
``track_number`` / ``disc_number`` keys when truthy.**
Pre-fix:
```python
matched_data = { 'id': ..., 'name': ..., ... } # no track_number / disc_number
if track_number:
matched_data['track_number'] = track_number
if disc_number:
matched_data['disc_number'] = disc_number
```
Deezer-sourced matches always hit this branch with ``track_number=None``
because the cache enrichment at line 304 reads ``_raw.get('track_number')``
literally, but Deezer's raw shape uses ``track_position``. So the key
was omitted from ``matched_data``, downstream consumers couldn't
distinguish "missing key" from "value is 1", and the chain silently
filled 1.
Post-fix: keys are ALWAYS present (None when unknown). Also adds a
``best_match.track_number`` fallback so the Track-dataclass-mapped
value (which DOES include ``track_position``→``track_number``
mapping) gets used when the cache lookup misses.
**Fix C — Pipeline only consulted ``album_info.track_number`` before
falling to the filename (``core/imports/pipeline.py:645``).**
VA-collection source files like ``417 Fountains of Wayne - Stacys
Mom.flac`` have a leading playlist-position number that isn't the
album track number. The previous chain (album_info → filename →
floor-1) couldn't recover the real position because the filename
extractor either returned 417 (wrong) or None (caught by the floor).
But the wishlist payload's ``track_info.spotify_data.track_number``
HAD the right answer all along — Spotify says Stacy's Mom is track
3 on Welcome Interstate Managers.
Post-fix: resolution chain extracted into ``core/imports/track_number.py:resolve_track_number``
as a pure function:
1. ``album_info.track_number`` (album-bundle dispatch authoritative)
2. ``track_info.track_number`` (per-track flow payload)
3. ``track_info.spotify_data.track_number`` (nested fallback)
4. ``extract_explicit_track_number(file_path)`` (filename, returns
0 when no numeric prefix — vs the default helper that returns 1)
5. Caller (pipeline) applies the final >=1 floor
Each step coerces to a positive int or falls through to the next.
Pure function = unit-testable in isolation = single place to fix
the rule.
**Test coverage (37 new tests):**
- ``tests/wishlist/test_payloads.py`` (+4) — Track→dict conversion
preserves full album dict (dict / object / string album shapes) +
None-track-number stays None.
- ``tests/discovery/test_discovery_playlist.py`` (+2) — matched_data
always includes track_number/disc_number keys (None when unknown)
+ falls back to best_match attrs when cache misses.
- ``tests/imports/test_track_number_resolver.py`` (+16) — every
resolution-chain branch pinned: album_info-wins, track_info
fallback, spotify_data nested, JSON-string parsing, garbage-string
fall-through, zero / negative / non-numeric / string-numeric
coercion, filename fallback, explicit extractor vs default
extractor semantics, defensive None inputs, VA-collection
filename behaviour, all-sources-missing → None.
1571 wider-suite tests pass (wishlist + imports + discovery +
downloads + metadata). Ruff clean.
**Migration note:** existing wishlist rows that were saved under
the OLD ``track_object_to_dict`` (with stripped album metadata) still
have ``release_date=''`` in the DB blob. Those won't self-heal — the
next attempt loads from the poisoned blob. Users can remove + re-add
those tracks to refresh, or wait for the next sync run that
re-discovers them with full metadata. No automatic migration shipped
in this PR (scope creep — the forward path is fixed, backfill is a
separate concern).
Two confirmed-from-code-reading bugs in the wishlist retry chain.
Both cause downstream post-process to render every retried file as
``01 - <title>`` without year in the folder path, even when the
source slskd file had the correct track number embedded and Spotify
had the album release date.
**Bug A — track_number defaults to 1 at every link in the chain.**
Pre-fix: ``.get('track_number', 1)`` defaulted at four sites:
- ``core/wishlist/payloads.py:121`` ``ensure_wishlist_track_format``
- ``core/wishlist/payloads.py:282`` Track-object conversion
- ``core/imports/context.py:421`` legacy album-info builder
- ``core/imports/pipeline.py:645`` final processing read
Each step "filled in" 1 when the upstream had dropped the key. The
downstream filename-extract fallback at ``pipeline.py:652`` ONLY
runs when the value is None — pre-filled 1 never matched, so the
fallback never fired, so the source filename's track number (e.g.
``08. No Sleep Till Brooklyn.flac``) was discarded in favour of the
default-1.
Fix: change every default from ``1`` to ``None`` along the chain.
The pipeline already has the right detect-and-recover logic — it
just needs the chain to stop poisoning it. Final ``< 1`` floor at
``pipeline.py:660`` still defaults to 1 as last resort, so callers
that genuinely have nothing still produce a valid number.
**Bug B — release_date dropped from cancelled-task wishlist payload.**
Pre-fix: ``build_cancelled_task_wishlist_payload`` only ``setdefault``ed
``name`` / ``album_type`` / ``images`` on the album dict. The
release_date field copy was load-bearing (when input was a dict, the
``dict(album_raw)`` copy preserved it), but when input was a bare
string the constructed dict had only name + album_type — no
release_date / total_tracks / etc.
Fix:
- Explicit comment on the dict-shape branch that release_date survives
via the unconditional ``dict(album_raw)`` copy + setdefault
semantics — so a future refactor that switches to a stricter copy
doesn't silently strip the field.
- String-shape branch now pulls release_date from
``track_info.album_release_date`` or ``track_info.release_date``
when present so the round-trip preserves the year for the path
template.
- track_data shape itself now carries ``track_number`` / ``disc_number``
at the top level (Bug A intersect — was dropping it entirely).
**Tests:** 4 new in tests/wishlist/test_payloads.py:
- ``test_ensure_wishlist_track_format_preserves_real_track_number``
- ``test_ensure_wishlist_track_format_keeps_missing_track_number_as_none``
- ``test_build_cancelled_task_wishlist_payload_preserves_track_number``
- ``test_build_cancelled_task_wishlist_payload_string_album_pulls_release_date_from_track_info``
14 payload tests pass; 879 across wishlist + imports + downloads
suites still green; 1410 wider suite all pass. Ruff clean.
Commits 2 + 3 of 3 in PR 2/4 of the wishlist-album-bundle issue fix
series. Commit 1 (94ba1d73) instrumented staging-match so the next
wishlist run produces the evidence we need to diagnose bug C
(staging-match silently drops album-bundle wishlist tracks); that
fix lands in a follow-up PR after the user's next reproduction run.
Closes#584. Quarantined files used to sit in ss_quarantine/ with a
thin sidecar — no UI, no recovery, no way to see what got dropped.
This adds the management surface the user needs without going to the
filesystem.
UI: new "Quarantine" button on the downloads page header opens a
modal with every quarantined file (filename, expected track/artist,
reason, when, size). Three actions per row:
- Approve (one-click): restores the file, re-runs the post-process
pipeline with ONLY the failing check skipped, lands in the library
with full tags + lyrics + scan
- Recover (legacy fallback): moves to Staging for thin-sidecar
entries that lack the embedded context Approve needs
- Delete: permanent removal of file + sidecar
Per-check bypass: context['_skip_quarantine_check'] = 'integrity' /
'acoustid' / 'bit_depth'. Skips ONLY the named check — other quality
gates stay live. No blanket bypass-all flag.
Sidecar expansion: move_to_quarantine now persists the full
json-serializable context via serialize_quarantine_context (drops
non-JSON-safe values, walks nested dicts/lists/sets, str-coerces
unknown objects) plus the trigger name. Existing thin sidecars are
detected and routed to Recover instead of Approve.
Pure helpers in core/imports/quarantine.py: list_quarantine_entries
/ delete_quarantine_entry / approve_quarantine_entry /
recover_to_staging / serialize_quarantine_context. 27 tests pin
every shape: orphan files / orphan sidecars / corrupt sidecars /
collision-safe filename restoration / full-context vs thin-sidecar
dispatch / json round-trip safety.
Four new endpoints in web_server.py — thin glue around the helpers:
GET /api/quarantine/list, DELETE /api/quarantine/<id>,
POST /api/quarantine/<id>/approve, POST /api/quarantine/<id>/recover.
Download modal status differentiates "🛡️ Quarantined" from
"❌ Failed" so recoverable files are visible at a glance — checked
against the error_message text, no schema change needed.
Pipeline changes are three minimal per-check conditionals at the
existing quarantine sites in core/imports/pipeline.py. Each
move_to_quarantine call now passes its trigger name so the sidecar
records which check fired.
Full suite: 2992 passed.
Previously hardcoded at 3s (5s for tracks >10min) — files drifting
past that got quarantined with no user override. Live recordings,
alternate masterings, and some legitimate uploads routinely drift
further.
New setting `post_processing.duration_tolerance_seconds`. Default 0
means "use auto-scaled defaults" (unchanged behavior for users who
don't touch it). Positive value overrides the per-track defaults.
Capped at 60s — past that the check is effectively off.
Logic lifted to pure helper `resolve_duration_tolerance` in
file_integrity.py. Coerces every plausible input (None / empty /
zero / negative / unparseable / above-cap / numeric string / float)
to either a float override or None for auto. 12 tests pin every
shape.
Wired into `core/imports/pipeline.py` at the integrity-check call
site — runs for ALL matched downloads (Soulseek / Tidal / Qobuz /
HiFi / YouTube / Deezer-direct) since they all share that pipeline.
Settings UI input under Settings → Metadata → Post-Processing.
User caught downloading Kendrick Mr. Morale: three tracks (Rich
Interlude, Savior Interlude, Savior) showed ✅ Completed in the modal
but were missing on disk. Log forensics revealed two layered bugs.
Bug 1 — Verification wrapper assumed success on quarantined files
(`core/imports/pipeline.py`):
The outer `post_process_matched_download_with_verification` had a
fallback at the "no `_final_processed_path` in context" branch that
marked the task completed and notified `success=True`. The inner
post-processor sets `_final_processed_path` only when the file
actually reaches its destination. Integrity-rejected files
(`_integrity_failure_msg` set) and race-guard-failed files
(`_race_guard_failed` set) get quarantined or skipped without ever
setting `_final_processed_path`, so they fell straight into the
"assume success" branch.
Confirmed in user's log:
No _final_processed_path in context for task d5b88b84-... —
cannot verify, assuming success
That line fired for the same task right after the integrity check
quarantined the source file. Result: ✅ Completed in UI, file in
quarantine, never delivered.
Fix: explicit checks for `_integrity_failure_msg` and
`_race_guard_failed` markers BEFORE the assume-success fallback.
Either marker set → task status='failed' with descriptive
error_message + `_notify_download_completed(success=False)`. The
pre-existing assume-success behavior preserved when no failure
markers are set (some legitimate flows complete without setting
`_final_processed_path`).
Bug 2 — AcoustID skip-logic too lenient
(`core/acoustid_verification.py`):
The "language/script" exemption was:
if best_score >= 0.95 and (title_sim >= 0.55 or
artist_sim >= ARTIST_MATCH_THRESHOLD):
The OR-clause fired for English-vs-English titles by the same artist
that share NO actual content. Confirmed in user's log: requested
"Rich (Interlude)" by Kendrick Lamar, AcoustID identified the audio
as "R.O.T.C. (interlude)" by Kendrick Lamar (a totally different
song from his 2010 mixtape) — same artist scored ≥ARTIST threshold,
shared word "interlude" pushed title_sim above 0.55, skip fired.
Verification returned SKIP instead of FAIL, the wrong file was
accepted as the answer for three different track requests.
Fix: skip now requires positive evidence the mismatch is a real
language/script case:
(a) Non-ASCII chars present in either title AND artist matches strongly
→ real transliteration case (kanji ↔ romaji etc)
(b) BOTH title_sim >= 0.80 AND artist_sim >= ARTIST threshold
→ minor punctuation/casing differences
English-vs-English with very different titles by the same artist no
longer skipped — verification correctly returns FAIL, the wrong file
gets quarantined, the new wrapper logic above marks the task failed.
Tests:
- `tests/test_integrity_failure_marks_task_failed.py` — 4 cases
pinning the wrapper-level state machine: integrity marker → failed,
race-guard marker → failed, no markers → still assumes success
(legacy path preserved), integrity-failure-takes-priority over
missing-final-path fallback.
- `tests/test_acoustid_skip_logic.py` — 7 cases pinning the skip
exemption: user's R.O.T.C-vs-Rich case → FAIL (regression test),
Savior-vs-R.O.T.C → FAIL (same bug surface), Japanese kanji →
romaji → SKIP (real language case still works), MAAD vs M.A.A.D →
PASS or SKIP (punctuation tolerance), low fingerprint score →
never skipped, high score but artist mismatch → no longer skipped,
Crown vs Crown of Thorns → no longer skipped.
Verified: full suite 1793 pass (11 new), ruff clean.
WHATS_NEW entry under '2.4.2' dev cycle.
Discord report (fresh.dumbledore [VRN]): slskd sometimes ships broken files
(truncated transfers, corrupt FLAC, wrong file substituted on filename match).
They flowed through post-processing and only surfaced later — Plex/Jellyfin
scan failures, dead-air playback, duplicate detector tripping over the wrong
length. By that point the file was already tagged, copied, mirrored to the
media server, and recorded in provenance.
New module `core/imports/file_integrity.py`:
- `check_audio_integrity(path, expected_duration_ms=None) -> IntegrityResult`
- Three tiered checks, cheapest to most expensive:
1. File size sanity (catches 0-byte stubs and stub transfers)
2. Mutagen parse (catches header damage, wrong-format-with-right-extension)
3. Duration agreement vs. metadata source's expected length, ±3s tolerance
(5s for tracks over 10 minutes — long tracks naturally drift more)
- Returns IntegrityResult with `ok`, human-readable `reason`, and per-check
`checks` dict for debugging
- Never raises; pathological inputs return ok=False with explanation
Pipeline integration in `core/imports/pipeline.py:post_process_matched_download`:
- Hooks between the existing file-stability wait and AcoustID verification
- On failure: quarantine via existing `move_to_quarantine` helper, mark task
failed with descriptive error, clear matched-context, fire
`on_download_completed(success=False)` so the slot is released for retry
- Mirrors the existing AcoustID-failure path so retry behavior stays consistent
- Wrapped in try/except so an unexpected failure inside the check itself
cannot block downloads — logs and continues
This is intentionally tier 1: universal across formats, no external deps.
A future tier could verify FLAC STREAMINFO MD5 by decoding audio (needs
flac binary or libflac wrapper) — skipped for now since tier 1 catches the
dominant Discord-reported cases (truncated, 0-byte, wrong file).
Tests:
- `tests/imports/test_file_integrity.py` — 14 cases covering all three check
tiers, edge cases (zero/negative expected duration, long-track wider
tolerance, caller tolerance override), and the mutagen-unavailable
degradation path
- `tests/imports/test_import_pipeline.py` — two existing tests use 5-byte
fixture files that the new check would reject; they monkeypatch the
integrity check since they're testing plumbing (notification +
metadata_runtime forwarding), not integrity behavior
WHATS_NEW entry under '2.4.2' dev cycle.
slskd appends "_<19-digit unix-nanosecond timestamp>" to a downloaded
filename when the destination already contains a same-named file
(concurrent downloads of the same track, partial-file retries after a
connection drop, cancelled-then-redownloaded files, the same track
surfacing in multiple synced playlists). The file-finder code already
recognized the suffix when matching a download to its source — but
after the canonical file moved into the library, the leftover
"_<timestamp>" siblings sat orphaned in the downloads folder forever.
Reported on Discord by Shdjfgatdif.
cleanup_slskd_dedup_siblings() runs at the end of each successful
import (3 safe_move_file sites in pipeline.py) and prunes any
remaining siblings that strip down to the canonical stem with the
same extension. Conservative match (>= 18 trailing digits) keeps
legitimate filenames like "Track 5" and "Album 1995" untouched. Per-
file unlink failures are swallowed so a single locked file doesn't
block the rest.
17 regression tests cover the suffix-strip primitive, orphan removal,
no-op cases, mismatched extensions, subdirectories, and partial-failure
recovery.
- add core/wishlist as the home for wishlist payload, resolution, state, processing, reporting, and selection helpers
- move wishlist-specific tests into tests/wishlist alongside the new package layout
- keep web_server.py and the import/search callers as thin adapters for now
- keep single-track import lookup in imports/resolution.py
- normalize simple-download search_result data before wishlist matching
- run wishlist cleanup for simple-download post-processing
- keep source-only artist detail on resolved names and MB short-circuit
- Move the import pipeline runtime factory into core.imports.pipeline
- Move the metadata runtime factory into core.metadata.enrichment
- Keep the web server wiring thin and drop the shared glue module
- Add contract tests that keep the two runtime bundles separate
- Relocate the shared metadata helper module from core/metadata_common.py into core/metadata/common.py.
- Update the new metadata package, the import pipeline, and the web entrypoint to use the package-scoped helper.
- Keep the shared config, mutagen, file-lock, and tag-writing helpers centralized without touching unrelated files.
- Pass the live runtime bundle into the shared metadata facade so worker-backed source enrichment can actually run.
- Forward runtime from the import pipeline and web-server wrapper into embed_source_ids.
- Add a regression test that verifies the runtime object reaches the source-ID embedding path.
- Keep existing metadata_cache and metadata_service at the top level for now
- Move the new branch-local metadata helpers under core/metadata
- Share MusicBrainz release cache state from core.metadata.source and update import sites
- Move app-wide task and activity registries out of core/imports
- Share one runtime-state module across the web server, API, and import pipeline
- Keep import-specific helpers focused on context and post-processing
- Move import flow modules into a dedicated package
- Update app and test imports to the new namespace
- Group the import-focused tests under tests/imports
