S-Bryce reported that for some artists (Vocaloid producers, JP indie
acts, niche Western indie) the artist detail page was missing whole
release-groups visible on musicbrainz.org. Downloaded tracks from
those release-groups appeared in artist track counts but were not
bound to any visible album / single card — orphan "ghost" tracks the
user couldn't browse to.
Two duplicated bugs fed each other:
1. `core/musicbrainz_search.py` browsed MB release-groups with
`release_types=['album', 'ep', 'single']`. MB's primary-type
vocabulary is {Album, Single, EP, Broadcast, Other} — music
videos, one-off web releases, and broadcast singles use Other.
Pre-fix the filter dropped them at the API layer.
2. Three sites duplicated the same "raw primary-type → internal
album_type" mapping with slightly different vocabularies and all
silently defaulted unknown values (including 'Other') to 'album':
core/musicbrainz_search.py `_map_release_type`
core/metadata/types.py inline `{single:single, ep:ep}.get(...)`
core/metadata/cache.py Deezer-specific record_type guard
Letting Other through the filter without a real mapper would have
placed music videos in the Albums view alongside LPs — visually
misleading.
Fix shape:
- New `core/metadata/release_type.py` — single canonical mapper
consumed by every provider's raw→Album projection. Knows the full
MB vocabulary including 'other' and 'broadcast'; routes both into
the singles bucket since they're functionally single-track
releases. Compilation secondary-type override preserved (MB's
canonical Greatest-Hits pattern is `primary=Album,
secondary=[Compilation]`).
- `core/musicbrainz_search.py` `_map_release_type` becomes a thin
alias for the new helper so the six internal call sites stay
intact. API filter gains 'other'.
- `core/metadata/types.py` Album projection drops its inline mini-
mapper and calls the canonical helper. Now also handles the
compilation secondary-type override it was previously missing.
- The Deezer-specific cache.py guard stays as-is — Deezer's
record_type vocabulary is closed (album|single|ep), not affected
by this issue.
Verified end-to-end against MB for S-Bryce's artist (`46196b9c-affa-
4616-b53b-e967c8bd70e0`, inabakumori): pre-fix returned 22 release-
groups; post-fix returns 27, with the 5 extra all landing in the
Singles section with album_type='single' as intended.
23 new unit tests pin the mapper contract (case-insensitive primary
types, compilation secondary override, Other/Broadcast → single,
unknown → album default preserved, defensive empty/None inputs).
2 new tests in test_musicbrainz_search pin the API filter inclusion
of 'other' and the round-trip into the Singles bucket. All 516
existing metadata tests still green — refactor leaves historical
behaviour for {album, ep, single, compilation} unchanged.
The Fix Track Match modal's auto-search was hardcoded to query only
Spotify -> Deezer -> iTunes, ignoring MusicBrainz entirely — even for
users with MB set as their primary metadata source. MB-niche recordings
(canonical entries with diacritics, fringe / non-mainstream tracks that
the commercial catalogues don't carry) had no chance.
Wiring:
- New `MusicBrainzSearchClient.search_tracks_with_artist(track, artist,
limit)` for surfaces that already have title + artist split. Uses MB's
bare-query mode (strict=False) — diacritic-folded, alias/sortname
indexed — same recall rationale as the earlier MBID-paste endpoint.
- New route `GET /api/musicbrainz/search_tracks` mirrors the existing
/api/{spotify,itunes,deezer}/search_tracks endpoints exactly: accepts
`track`+`artist` (or legacy `query`) + `limit`, returns
`{tracks: [{id, name, artists, album, duration_ms, image_url, source}]}`.
Applies the same `core.metadata.relevance.rerank_tracks` pass Deezer /
iTunes use, which is critical because MB's free-text scoring weighs
title-text matches heavily and would otherwise rank cover / tribute
recordings above the canonical version.
- `_search_tracks_text` gains a `min_score` parameter. The cascade path
passes 20 (vs the enhanced-search-tab default of 80) so MB recordings
whose title doesn't literally contain the artist name still enter the
candidate pool — without that, "Army of Me" + "Bjork" only surfaces
the HIRS Collective cover (score 100) and drops Björk's canonical
recording (score 28). The rerank pass then surfaces Björk by artist
match. Verified against real MB API: pre-fix returned only the cover;
post-fix top 5 are all Björk.
- Fix popup `allSources` array (wishlist-tools.js) gets MB appended.
The existing `activeIdx` reorder logic moves MB to the front when
it's the active primary; otherwise MB sits last (1 req/sec rate
limit makes it the slowest source).
7 new unit tests on the adapter: bare-query mode is used, missing
artist falls back to None (drops AND-clause), empty inputs short-circuit,
low-score candidates are kept for rerank to handle, default strict +
default min_score behaviour preserved for the existing search-tab path,
client errors are swallowed so the cascade falls through to the next
source.
Discogs intentionally absent — Discogs has no track-level search API
(see core/discogs_client.py:575 — returns []). Adding a Flask endpoint
that always returns empty would be a permanent no-op.
Power-user escape hatch on the Discovery Fix Track Match modal — when
fuzzy auto-search ranks the wrong recording among many same-title
versions (10 remasters, live cuts, alt sessions), paste the MusicBrainz
recording URL or bare UUID into the new field and resolve straight to
that record.
Layout:
- Shape adapter `get_recording_flat(mbid)` lives in
`core/musicbrainz_search.py` next to existing `get_track_details`.
Returns the flat Fix-popup track shape (artists as `string[]`,
album as string, single `image_url`) — distinct from the
Spotify-shaped nested dict `get_track_details` returns.
- New route `GET /api/musicbrainz/recording/<mbid>` is a thin wrapper:
validates MBID format with an anchored UUID regex, calls the adapter,
returns 400 / 404 / 200 with no inline shape massaging.
- Frontend `parseMusicBrainzMbid()` lives in `shared-helpers.js` —
pure URL/UUID parser, reusable from other surfaces (failed-MB cache,
manual match) without duplication.
- Fix modal HTML gets one new input row + button; existing search row
and result render pipeline are untouched. New `lookupDiscoveryFixByMbid()`
fetches the endpoint and feeds the single result through the existing
`renderDiscoveryFixResults` -> confirm-dialog -> match pipeline, so MB-
paste matches go through the exact same selection flow as auto-search
results.
- Enter-key bound on the MBID input via a separate handler ref so its
lifecycle matches the search-input handlers without conflating the
two submit targets.
7 unit tests cover the adapter: happy path, empty/None MBID, MB returns
None, recording-without-release (empty album), multi-artist credits,
includes-list contract, and client-error swallow.
Out of scope: the Fix popup's fuzzy cascade is still hardcoded to
spotify/deezer/itunes regardless of which primary source the user has
configured. Adding MB to that cascade (when MB is the active primary)
is a separate concern.
Two bugs surfacing on the Fix popup and enhanced-search MB tab:
1. Strict Lucene phrase queries (`recording:"X" AND artist:"Y"`) killed
recall on user-facing manual search — diacritics ("Bjork" vs canonical
"Björk"), bracketed suffixes like "(Live)", and any AND-clause
mismatch returned zero results. Added `strict: bool = True` param to
`search_release` / `search_recording`; when False, sends a bare query
joining title + artist so MB hits alias/sortname indexes with
diacritic folding. `/api/musicbrainz/search` (Fix popup) and
`core/library/service_search.py` (service tabs) now pass strict=False.
Enrichment workers stay on strict mode — precision matters there
because they auto-accept the top hit above a confidence threshold.
2. Every MB album click was silently 404-ing — `_render_release_as_album`
passed `cover-art-archive` as an MB `inc` param, but it's not a valid
include for the /release resource (MB rejects with 400). The CAA flags
come back on every release response by default, so dropping the bad
include preserves the image-scope picker logic intact.
- Move the metadata and MusicBrainz-related tests into a dedicated tests/metadata subfolder.
- Keep the rest of the suite flat for now.
- Preserve the existing test filenames so the change stays organizational rather than behavioral.
2026-04-27 19:54:44 +03:00
Renamed from tests/test_musicbrainz_search.py (Browse further)
